3. Measuring Outcomes

MODULE 2 | Section 3 of 8

Measuring Outcomes

MEASURING OUTCOMES THAT MATTER TO PATIENTS

The purpose of measuring outcomes is to enable and accelerate learning and improvement in health care delivery. If you find yourself asking, “Matters to whom?” the obvious answer is: what matters to patients. The reason for health care is to help patients and families.
Facts are friendly. While physicians may worry about what outcome measurement may reveal, the opportunity to learn and improve is enabled tremendously by measuring results. When you can identify successes and failures, as well as where outcomes succeed or fail by dimension, you gain critical insight about how to improve. Putting in place measurement, feedback, and learning processes enables one patient’s outcomes to inform treatment of the next patient with similar circumstances. Physicians who don’t track outcomes for their patients lack the feedback and tools to enable rapid learning and ongoing improvement. This points to a fundamental tenant of value-based health care: to get ever-better results for your patients and to do so efficiently.
To learn how better (or worse) outcomes are being achieved, you need to analyze the processes that lead to those outcomes. Process improvement methodology is widely used in most sectors of the economy, but less often in health care. When it is used in health care, it is often applied within departmental or procedural silos, rather than across the full cycle of the patient’s care journey. This fractured view of health care slows improvement and innovation; to really understand how desired outcomes may be achieved, processes must be viewed holistically.

ADDITIONAL RESOURCES

You can watch a 4-minute video of Maureen Bisognano describing the story of her brother and the impact of focusing on

“What Matters to You?”

“If my grand-daughter is admitted to your hospital, I expect three things from you:

 

1. Do not harm her


2. Heal her


3. Be nice to her”

– A grandfather and physician

CAPABILITY, COMFORT, AND CALM

One framework for considering patient outcomes, proposed by Elizabeth Teisberg and Scott Wallace from Dell Medical School, is “Capability, Comfort, and Calm.”2-5
Teisberg and Wallace popularized the idea that the key question about satisfaction with health care is “How are you?” rather than “How were we?” or “Would you recommend your physician?” They have written that, “While there are hundreds of possible performance measures for physicians, the critical questions […] are about the patients, not just about the doctor’s performance. Patient results determine quality of life and are therefore the most important measure of physician performance.”2

CAPABILITY

Refers to functional outcomes such as survival, extent of recovery, and ability to perform activities necessary or desired in day-to-day life. Capability matters both during care and as a result of care.

COMFORT

Lessening the burden of disease or injury. This includes reducing physical and emotional pain and suffering. Comfort also matters both during and after care.

CALM

Lessening the burden of treatment. This includes measures related to the amount of time or days lost to treatment or to managing care and payment, the ability to work, and the amount of chaos introduced or avoided.
Capability, comfort and calm are categories, within which measures can be specified. These measures can be collected directly from patients as easily as patient satisfaction data are collected. The difference is that we get insight about how well our patients are doing with health, rather than how they reacted to parking, wait times, or hospitality. These patient-reported outcome measures are discussed in the next section.

REFERENCES

  1. 1- Institute for healthcare improvement. “Changing the Conversation from, ‘What’s the Matter?’ to ‘What Matters to You?’” Maureen Bisognano keynote presentation at the 13th Annual International Summit on Improving Patient Care in the Office Practice and the Community, March 2012.
  2.  
  3. 2- Teisberg E, Wallace S. Capability, Comfort and Calm: Designing Health Care Services for Excellence and Empathy [presentation]. Cleveland, OH: Patient Experience, Empathy Innovation Summit, May 16, 2016.
  4.  
  5. 3- Wallace S, Teisberg EO, Measuring What Matters: Connecting Excellence, Professionalism and EmpathyBrain Injury Professional , September 2015.
  6.  
  7. 4- Teisberg E, Wallace S. Value for PatientsBrain Injury Professional, September 2015.
  8.  
  9. 5- Teisberg E, Wallace S. The Quality Tower of BabelHealth Affairs Blog, April 13, 2015.

Leave a Comment